For the thousands of mourners inside Johannesburg's FNB Stadium it was meant to be a fitting tribute to a 'giant of history'.
But
while some reflected on the remarkable life of Nelson Mandela, some
world leaders saw it as the perfect opportunity to grab a quick 'selfie'
with their peers.
Perhaps
not in keeping with the tone of a memorial service, US President Barack
Obama, Prime Minister David Cameron and Danish leader Helle
Thorning-Schmidt grinned as they cosied up for a quick picture at
today's memorial service for the former South African president,
prompting an outpouring of criticism.
As the trio posed for the mobile phone snap, Obama's wife Michelle sat alongside her husband looking less than impressed.
Obama
had earlier paid an emotional tribute to Nelson Mandela, calling the
South African leader a 'giant of history' as he spoke in a stadium where
around a third of the seats were mysteriously left empty.
Selfie: David Cameron and Barack Obama took a picture of themselves alongside Denmark's prime minister Helle Thorning-Schmidt
President Barack Obama and Danish prime minister, Helle Thorning-Schmidt chat during the ceremony
Mrs Thorning-Schmidt then points out something of interest in the order of service
They then share a joke during the poignant memorial to Nelson Mandela
Obama and the Danish Prime Minister share a joke during the memorial service as the First Lady looks on unimpressed
Eulogy: U.S. President Obama waves to the crowd
as he delivers his speech at the memorial service for Nelson Mandela in
Johannesburg
Passion: Mr Obama spoke of how he was inspired by Mandela's political mission when he began his own career
Fitting setting: A general view of the arena
which was the location of Mr Mandela's first speech in Johannesburg
after he was released from prison in 1990
Rare display of unity: President Obama shakes
hands with Cuban leader Raul Castro in spite of the animosity between
their governments
Historic: The handshake between Obama and Fidel
Castro's brother Raul came during a ceremony that focused on Mandela's
legacy of reconciliation
'His triumph was your triumph': President
Barrack Obama is shown on a big screen as he delivers his eulogy to
flag-waving and umbrella-holding mourners
Mutual respect: President Obama speaks to Nelson Mandela's widow Graca Machel during the memorial service
Giving his condolences: President Obama kisses Nelson Mandela's widow Graca Machel during the memorial service
The image of the US
president, British Prime Minister and Danish leader - who is married to
Neil Kinnock's son, Stephen, who did not appear to be at the event -
taking the photo quickly went viral on the internet.
It
led to a backlash from Twitter users who said it was inappropriate
behaviour at an event to remember the life of the anti-apartheid hero,
who died last week aged 95.
Twitter user James Armitage
wrote: 'What selfish morons take a 'selfie' at a memorial service? Oh
yeah that's right, Barack Obama and David Cameron.'
In a message directed at Mr Cameron, Sarah McDermott said: 'You have precisely zero class or decorum.'
Writing
on Twitter, Mel Huang said: 'I wonder if Neil Kinnock got an ulcer
seeing his daughter-in-law do a selfie with David Cameron...at a
memorial service.'
President Obama, who moments earlier had
shaken hands with Cuba's Raul Castro in a historic moment of
reconciliation, receivied a rapturous reception for his eulogy at the
service in Johannesburg's FNB Stadium, which started an hour late in the
pouring rain.
Cyril
Ramaphosa, the deputy president of the ruling ANC party who opened the
proceedings, said: 'In our tradition, when it rains when you are buried,
your gods are welcoming you to heaven.'
Leaders: Tony Abbott, John Key and David
Cameron, prime ministers of Australia, New Zealand and Britain
respectively, at the service
Representatives: David Cameron and Nick Clegg were attending the ceremony along with three former Prime Ministers of Britain
Arrival: Mr Cameron, Mr Clegg and John Major walking in to the FNB Stadium this morning
Dignitaries: Sir John Major and Tony Blair were two of the former Prime Ministers of the UK to attend in honour of Mandela
Support: Gordon Brown, who paid tribute to Mandela in the Commons yesterday, with his wife Sarah and George W. Bush
SYMBOLIC HANDSHAKE THAT COULD CHANGE HISTORY
Today's
handshake between Barack Obama and Raul Castro was an extraordinary
symbolic moment, which could show that the two presidents are ready to
improve ties between their countries.
Cuba and the U.S. were extremely close for decades, before an army led by Fidel Castro and Che Guevara overthrew the government of the island nation in 1959.
The next year, America imposed an economic embargo against Cuba in the hope of weakening the regime.
The U.S. views Cuba with suspicion because of its Communist government, while Castro's regime has long regarded America as its bitterest enemy.
After Fidel resigned as president in 2008 due to ill-health, there were hopes that his brother Raul might prove less hostile to the U.S., but relations do not seem to have thawed before today.
The two leaders' handshake could be a false dawn, however, as the two countries have looked close to a diplomatic breakthrough in the past before backsliding towards hostility.
Cuba and the U.S. were extremely close for decades, before an army led by Fidel Castro and Che Guevara overthrew the government of the island nation in 1959.
The next year, America imposed an economic embargo against Cuba in the hope of weakening the regime.
The U.S. views Cuba with suspicion because of its Communist government, while Castro's regime has long regarded America as its bitterest enemy.
After Fidel resigned as president in 2008 due to ill-health, there were hopes that his brother Raul might prove less hostile to the U.S., but relations do not seem to have thawed before today.
The two leaders' handshake could be a false dawn, however, as the two countries have looked close to a diplomatic breakthrough in the past before backsliding towards hostility.
Mr
Obama arrived almost an hour after the ceremony started, but was
greeted with prolonged applause by the crowd - in stark contrast to
South African president Jacob Zuma, who was loudly booed whenever he
appeared on the stadium's big screen.
When
Mr Zuma walked up to the podium to deliver the keynote speech at the
ceremony, he was met with a huge chorus of boos, forcing organisers to
bring in a choir to drown out the noise of the crowd and save the
president's blushes.
Mr Obama opened his
speech by thanking Mandela's family, then continued: 'To the people of
South Africa - people of every race and walk of life - the world thanks
you for sharing Nelson Mandela with us.
'His
struggle was your struggle. His triumph was your triumph. Your dignity
and hope found expression in his life, and your freedom, your democracy
is his cherished legacy.'
He
continued: 'Mandela taught us the power of action, but also ideas; the
importance of reason and arguments; the need to study not only those you
agree with, but those who you don't.'
Referring
to the anti-apartheid icon's friendship with his own prison warders,
the President said: 'It took a man like Madiba to free not just the
prisoner, but the gaoler as well.'
He also spoke out against the
dictators from countries such as Zimbabwe and China who pay lip service
to Mandela's legacy while repressing their own people, saying: 'There
are too many of us who happily embrace Madiba's legacy of racial
reconciliation, but passionately resist even modest reforms that would
challenge chronic poverty and growing inequality.
'There
are too many leaders who claim solidarity with Madiba's struggle for
freedom, but do not tolerate dissent from their own people. And there
are too many of us who stand on the sidelines, comfortable in
complacency or cynicism when our voices must be heard.'
Sombre occasion: Members of Nelson Mandela's
family take their seats amid heavy rain ahead of his memorial service
at the FNB Stadium in Soweto, near Johannesburg
Prominent role: U.S. President Barack Obama, who will deliver a eulogy at the service, is joined by First Lady Michelle (right)
Cheers: When America's first couple flashed up on screen the crowd roared their approval of the U.S.'s first black President
Tough conditions: Mr Obama was delayed because his motorcade struggled through the rain-soaked route to the World Cup stadium
Two very different receptions: Mr Obama, who was
greeted with prolonged applause, embraces South African president Jacob
Zuma, who was loudly booed
Embarrassing: South African Jacob Zuma was roundly booed by the crowd when he got up to deliver his tribute to Mr Mandela
Mr
Obama concluded: 'We will never see the likes of Nelson Mandela again.
But let me say to the young people of Africa, and young people around
the world - you can make his life's work your own.'
On
his way to the podium, the President shook hands with Raul Castro,
whose brother Fidel has long been one of the fiercest enemies of the
U.S. - testament to Mandela's ability to bring warring parties together
in his memory.
The two
countries have not had diplomatic relations since the Communist
revolution of 1959, and their leaders are not believed to have
communicated with each other in recent years.
Among the other international
dignitaries to attend the event are several current and former British
leaders, including David Cameron, Nick Clegg, Gordon Brown, Tony Blair
and John Major.
The memorial
featured tributes by some of the anti-Apartheid icon's family and a
speech from United Nations Secretary General Ban Ki-moon.
Mr
Ban told the service: ‘South Africa has lost a hero, we have lost a
father and the world has lost a beloved friend and mentor.
‘Nelson
Mandela was more than one of the greatest leaders of our time, he was
one of our greatest teachers. He taught by example, he sacrificed so
much and was willing to give up everything for freedom, equality and
justice.
‘His compassion stands out most.’
Relatives: Mr Mandela's ex-wife Winnie Mandela
Madikizela (left) and his widow Graca Machel (far right) take their
seats in the stadium
Emotional: Winnie Madikizela-Mandela (left) and
Graca Machel (right) fight back tears as moving tributes to Mr Mandela
are read out
Nelson Mandela's former wife Winnie Mandela
Madikizela (left) and his widow Graca Machel embrace at his memorial
service. The two women are close and refer to each other as 'sisters'
Mourning: Mr Mandela's former wife Winnie
Mandela Madikizela (centre), who famously greeted her husband as he left
prison, arrives at the ceremony
Family affair: (front row) Mr Mandela's
daughters Zindzi, Zenani and Makaziwe Mandela, ex-wife Winnie Mandela
Madikizela and widow Graca Machel before the service
A HERO OF OUR TIME: THE TRIBUTES PAID TO NELSON MANDELA BY THE WORLD'S LEADERS
UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon said 'the world has lost a beloved friend and mentor'
UN secretary-general Ban Ki-moon: 'South Africa has lost a hero, we have lost a father and the world has lost a beloved friend and mentor.
'Nelson Mandela was more than one of the greatest leaders of our time, he was one of our greatest teachers.
'He taught by example, he sacrificed so much and was willing to give up everything for freedom, equality and justice.
'His compassion stands out most.'
South Africa president Jacob Zuma: 'Today Madiba is no more. He leaves behind a nation that loves him dearly. He leaves a continent that is truly proud to call him an African.
South Africa president Jacob Zuma: 'Today Madiba is no more. He leaves behind a nation that loves him dearly. He leaves a continent that is truly proud to call him an African.
'United in our diversity we will continue to build a nation free of poverty, hunger, homelessness and inequality.'
Family member General Thanduxolo Mandela: 'To him, life was all about service to others.
Family member General Thanduxolo Mandela: 'To him, life was all about service to others.
'He mingled with kings, queens and presidents... At the core, he was a man of the people.'
Cuban President Raul Castro: 'Let
us pay tribute to Nelson Mandela: The ultimate symbol of dignity and
unwavering dedication to the revolutionary struggle, to freedom and
justice, a prophet of unity, peace and reconciliation.
'As
Mandela’s life teaches us, only the concerted effort of all nations
will empower humanity to respond to the enormous challenges that today
threatens its very existence.'
Brazilian President President Dilma Rousseff: 'He also was a source of inspiration for similar struggles in Brazil and across South America.
'His
fight reached way beyond his nation’s border and inspired young men and
women to fight for independence and social justice.'
Chinese Vice President Li Yuanchao: 'Mr. Mandela was the pride of the African people. He has dedicated his entire life to the development and progress of the African continent.'
Chinese Vice President Li Yuanchao: 'Mr. Mandela was the pride of the African people. He has dedicated his entire life to the development and progress of the African continent.'
Former Prime Minister Gordon Brown: 'His
life was just an extraordinary journey, from beginning to end, with
such an effect, both on his own country, and on the rest of the world.
We may not see his like again.'
The
event at the 95,000-capacity FNB Stadium in Soweto began with a
rendition of South Africa's national anthem - the first of several musical interludes.
However, when the speeches began, some in the huge stadium complained they could not hear over the sound of the crowd.
Mr
Ramaphosa told the crowd during his opening address: 'We wish to applaud
the people of South Africa for the dignified manner in which they have
honoured and remembered the memory of Nelson Mandela since he passed
away. We applaud you and thank you for it.'
After
interfaith prayers, the service then heard from Andrew Mlangeni, a
former prisoner on Robben Island with Mr Mandela, who spoke of the
'outpouring of love' following his death.
'Madiba
is looking down on us. There is no doubt he is smiling and he watches
his beloved country, men and women, unite to celebrate his life and
legacy,' he said.
Respect: Nelson Mandela is shown on a giant
screen inside the stadium as thousands of South Africans and global
dignitaries file into the ground
A man waves a South African flag: South Africans
have been praised for the 'dignified' way in which they have
commemorated Mr Mandela's death
Umbrella weather: The ceremony started an hour
late in the pouring rain to allow dignitaries and members of the public
to file in to the arena
Empty seats: The 94,000-capacity stadium was
reportedly only two-thirds full which may have due to the adverse
weather conditions
'THANK YOU FOR SHARING MADIBA': HIGHLIGHTS OF OBAMA'S HEARTFELT EULOGY FOR NELSON MANDELA
To the people of South Africa - people of every race and walk of life -
the world thanks you for sharing Nelson Mandela with us. His struggle
was your struggle. His triumph was your triumph.
Born during World War I, far from the corridors of power, a boy raised herding cattle and tutored by elders of his Thembu tribe - Madiba would emerge as the last great liberator of the 20th century.
He was not a bust made of marble; he was a man of flesh and blood - a son and husband, a father and a friend.
Mandela showed us the power of action; of taking risks on behalf of our ideals.
Mandela understood the ties that bind the human spirit. There is a word in South Africa - 'Ubuntu' - that describes his greatest gift: his recognition that we are all bound together in ways that can be invisible to the eye; that there is a oneness to humanity; that we achieve ourselves by sharing ourselves with others, and caring for those around us.
It took a man like Madiba to free not just the prisoner, but the gaoler as well; to show that you must trust others so that they may trust you; to teach that reconciliation is not a matter of ignoring a cruel past, but a means of confronting it with inclusion, generosity and truth. He changed laws, but also hearts.
There are too many of us who happily embrace Madiba’s legacy of racial reconciliation, but passionately resist even modest reforms that would challenge chronic poverty and growing inequality. There are too many leaders who claim solidarity with Madiba’s struggle for freedom, but do not tolerate dissent from their own people. And there are too many of us who stand on the sidelines, comfortable in complacency or cynicism when our voices must be heard.
We will never see the likes of Nelson Mandela again. But let me say to the young people of Africa, and young people around the world - you can make his life’s work your own. Over thirty years ago, while still a student, I learned of Mandela and the struggles in this land. It stirred something in me. It woke me up to my responsibilities - to others, and to myself - and set me on an improbable journey that finds me here today. And while I will always fall short of Madiba’s example, he makes me want to be better.
Born during World War I, far from the corridors of power, a boy raised herding cattle and tutored by elders of his Thembu tribe - Madiba would emerge as the last great liberator of the 20th century.
He was not a bust made of marble; he was a man of flesh and blood - a son and husband, a father and a friend.
Mandela showed us the power of action; of taking risks on behalf of our ideals.
Mandela understood the ties that bind the human spirit. There is a word in South Africa - 'Ubuntu' - that describes his greatest gift: his recognition that we are all bound together in ways that can be invisible to the eye; that there is a oneness to humanity; that we achieve ourselves by sharing ourselves with others, and caring for those around us.
It took a man like Madiba to free not just the prisoner, but the gaoler as well; to show that you must trust others so that they may trust you; to teach that reconciliation is not a matter of ignoring a cruel past, but a means of confronting it with inclusion, generosity and truth. He changed laws, but also hearts.
There are too many of us who happily embrace Madiba’s legacy of racial reconciliation, but passionately resist even modest reforms that would challenge chronic poverty and growing inequality. There are too many leaders who claim solidarity with Madiba’s struggle for freedom, but do not tolerate dissent from their own people. And there are too many of us who stand on the sidelines, comfortable in complacency or cynicism when our voices must be heard.
We will never see the likes of Nelson Mandela again. But let me say to the young people of Africa, and young people around the world - you can make his life’s work your own. Over thirty years ago, while still a student, I learned of Mandela and the struggles in this land. It stirred something in me. It woke me up to my responsibilities - to others, and to myself - and set me on an improbable journey that finds me here today. And while I will always fall short of Madiba’s example, he makes me want to be better.
Tributes were also made by General
Thanduxolo Mandela, and 'Madiba's' grandchildren Mbuso Mandela, Andile
Mandela, Zozuko Dlamini and Phumla Mandela.
Chinese
vice-president
Li Yuanchao, Brazilian president Dilma Roussef, Namibian
president Hifikepunye Pohamba and Indian president Pranab Mukherjee
also made speeches before a keynote address by South Africa's president
Jacob Zuma and a sermon by Bishop Ivan Abrahams.
Speaking
through a translator, Mr Castro said: 'Let us pay tribute to Nelson
Mandela: The ultimate symbol of dignity and unwavering dedication to the
revolutionary struggle, to freedom and justice, a prophet of unity,
peace and reconciliation.
'As
Mandela's life teaches us, only the concerted effort of all nations
will empower humanity to respond to the enormous challenges that today
threatens its very existence.'
In
her address, Ms Rousseff said: 'He also was a source of inspiration for
similar struggles in Brazil and across South America.
'His
fight reached way beyond his nation's border and inspired young men and
women to fight for independence and social justice.'
Mr
Li told how Mr Mandela was the 'pride of the African people', adding:
'He has dedicated his entire life to the development and progress of the
African continent.'
Mr Zuma
said: 'Today Madiba is no more. He leaves behind a nation that loves
him dearly. He leaves a continent that is truly proud to call him an
African.
'He leaves the
people of the world who embraced him as their own icon. Most
importantly, he leaves behind a deeply entrenched legacy of freedom,
human rights and democracy in our country.
'In
his honour we commit ourselves to continue building a nation based on
the democratic values of human dignity, equality and freedom. United in
our diversity we will continue to build a nation free of poverty,
hunger, homelessness and inequality.'
Crowds
started pouring in from early in the morning, undeterred by persistent
rain, and in the build-up to the ceremony mourners screamed in
celebration whenever members of Mandela's family appeared on the big
screen.
The rain, seen as a 'blessing' among South Africa's majority black population, enthused the crowd.
'In
our culture the rain is a blessing,' said Harry Tshabalala, a
government driver. 'Only great, great people are memorialised with it.
Rain is life. This is perfect weather for us on this occasion.'
Who's who of world leaders: VIPs and dignitaries watch from the tribune as rain lashes down during the memorial service
Paying tribute: World leaders converged on the
FNB Stadium in Soweto, the Johannesburg township that was a stronghold
of support for the anti-apartheid struggle that Mandela embodied
Rivals: But George W. Bush, pictured with wife
Laura, apparently got on well with his predecessor Bill Clinton,
pictured with wife Hillary and Chelsea
Wet, but well received: President Barack Obama greets members of the crowd in the pouring rain after making his speech
Homage: Obama paid an emotional tribute
to Nelson Mandela, thanking the people of South Africa for 'sharing'
their former president with the world
Leaving: Mr Obama waves to the camera as he walks out of the ceremony with the First Lady
Former president Bill Clinton and his wife,
former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton arrived separately but were
seen leaving together with their daughter Chelsea (third right) and aide
Huma Abedin (front)
However,
some of the dozens of trains laid on to ferry people to the stadium were
delayed due to a power failure. A Metrorail spokeswoman said more than
30,000 mourners were successfully transported by train.
When Mr Ramaphosa introduced the assembled dignitaries at the
start of the service, nearly all were welcomed by cheers - except
current president Jacob Zuma, whose name was met by loud booing.
Those
attended seemed to be in celebratory spirits, but the rain meant that
most of the uncovered lower section of the stadium was left empty.
Among
the mourners pictured arriving at the ceremony were former UN secretary
general Kofi Annan, ex-U.S. Secretary of State Henry Kissinger and
Desmond Tutu, the Archbishop of Cape Town who was Mandela's ally in
bringing apartheid to an end.
However,
Israel's president Benjamin Netanyahu decided not to attend,
because the cost of providing security for him would be too great.
In
addition, Xi Jinping of China, Hassan Rouhani of Iran and Russian
president Vladimir Putin were among the other prominent figures who
declined to travel to Johannesburg for the event.
A number of African presidents -
including the reviled Zimbabwean leader Robert Mugabe - arrived in South Africa overnight.
David Cameron paid tribute to the spirit of forgiveness shown by the anti-apartheid hero as he arrived for the service.
The
British prime minister said Mr Mandela set an example to politicians
across the world, not only in the 'incredible stand he took' but in the
way he treated people once he was released from prison.
Close ties: Supermodel Naomi Campbell, who Mr
Mandela described as his 'honorary granddaughter', enters the FNB
stadium ahead of the service
Controversial: Reviled Zimbabwean President Robert Mugabe is questioned by reporters as he makes his way into the stadium
Stars: U2 singer Bono and South African actress Charlize Theron talking in the crowd at the ceremony
Ally: FW de Klerk, who was awarded the Nobel
Prize along with Mandela for his role in ending apartheid, arrives with
his wife Elita
'He has done it again... people from all
walks of life, all here, united': UN Secretary General Ban Ki-Moon pays
tribute to Mr Mandela
Associates: Jimmy Carter, Kofi Annan and Henry Kissinger arrived at the memorial service together
RAIN SHOWS 'GODS ARE WELCOMING MANDELA HOME'
The rain that poured relentlessly during the memorial was seen as a good omen for Mr Mandela.
According to the former President's friend, Cyril Ramaphosa, the wet weather was seen in African traditions as the Gods welcoming home the dead.
He said: 'We were not able to stop the rain, but this is how Nelson Mandela would have wanted to be sent on. These are blessings.
'In the African tradition, it means the gods are welcoming you and the gates of heaven are open.'
The sentiments were echoed by others, who said it was a positive sign.
Defence Minister Nosiviwe Mapisa-Nqakula said: 'It's a blessing from the ancestors welcoming a son of the soil.'
The stadium announcer said the raindrops represented the 'heavens weeping'.
According to the former President's friend, Cyril Ramaphosa, the wet weather was seen in African traditions as the Gods welcoming home the dead.
He said: 'We were not able to stop the rain, but this is how Nelson Mandela would have wanted to be sent on. These are blessings.
'In the African tradition, it means the gods are welcoming you and the gates of heaven are open.'
The sentiments were echoed by others, who said it was a positive sign.
Defence Minister Nosiviwe Mapisa-Nqakula said: 'It's a blessing from the ancestors welcoming a son of the soil.'
The stadium announcer said the raindrops represented the 'heavens weeping'.
He
highlighted the moment Mr Mandela appeared with captain of the
Springboks Francois Pienaar at the Rugby World Cup final in South Africa
in 1995.
Mr Cameron
told BBC Breakfast: 'I will never forget the sight of him with the
captain of the Springboks out in the middle of that rugby pitch, that
moment is seared in all our memories.
'And the way that he had treated people who had done such harm to people.
'I
think it was the forgiveness that set an example that so few
politicians are able to follow. I think those sort of lessons are what
we need to learn and take away with us.'
After
the ceremony, Mr Cameron tweeted: 'An inspiring day - one that
challenges all leaders to live up to the spirit of Nelson Mandela.'
Asked
about his decision to wear a black tie, Mr Cameron said: 'We were told
that it was appropriate to wear a black tie but when you come and you
hear this great noise and great atmosphere of celebration, it's clear
that people here in South Africa want to, yes, say goodbye to this great
man, yes, commemorate what he did, but also celebrate his life and
celebrate his legacy and I think that's right.'
The
presence of Sir John Major, Tony Blair and Gordon Brown with Mr Cameron
reflects the deep respect in which Mr Mandela is held within British
politics.
The Prime
Minister and Mr Brown were among MPs who paid tribute to Mr Mandela in a
special Commons session yesterday following the Nobel peace
prize-winner's death.
Mr Brown added his tribute to 'the man that taught us no injustice can last forever'.
He
said: 'Nelson Mandela, the greatest man of his generation, yes, but
across generations, one of the most courageous people you could ever
hope to meet.'
Before today's ceremony, the former
Prime Minister added: 'His life was just an extraordinary journey, from
beginning to end, with such an effect, both on his own country, and on
the rest of the world.
'So, enjoy today, enjoy and celebrate what he achieved. We may not see his like again.'
Jovial: Former UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan
(left) and retired Anglican Archbishop Desmond Tutu appear in good
spirits as they arrive for the service
Embraced: Former British Prime Minister Tony Blair (left) is greeted after arriving for the memorial service in Johannesburg
Sense of humour: Former President of Ireland
Mary Robinson (left) chats with Archbishop Emeritus Desmond Tutu arrive
inside the FNB stadium
Successor: Former South African President Thabo
Mbeki is welcomed as he arrives at the FNB Stadium before heading
inside the venue with his wife Zanele (left)
Audience: Italian prime minister Enrico Letta
(above left), French ex-president Nicolas Sarkozy (below left) and his
successor Francois Hollande (below right)
Key role: Cuban President Raul Castro Ruz arrives for the memorial service where he is due to give a speech
Speaking to the BBC after the ceremony, Mr Blair said the service was 'extraordinary'.
Asked
for his memories of Mr Mandela, Mr Blair said: 'What I remember was how
easy he was to get on with. I have still got the pictures of my little
boy Leo just after he was born sitting on his knee when Mandela came to
the Labour Party conference in the year 2000.
'He
was so good with everyone, so easy with everyone, he was very
determined, not to turn into, as Barack Obama said earlier, a sort of
"marble bust", a sort of remote figure. He was very human and great fun.
'He
was always reaching out to people, always trying to reconcile them and
bringing people together and he did it in a way where there was
something quite transcendent about it.
'It was uncanny, his ability to reach people, not just on an emotional but almost on a spiritual level.'
Mr Miliband tweeted afterwards: 'Leaving the Mandela memorial service. A unique occasion, inspiring, moving and uplifting.'
The highest spots: Spectators gather ahead of the Tuesday memorial ceremony
Colourful: A woman dressed in the regalia of the South African national rugby team arriving at the stadium
Celebration: A mourner wearing a wig in the South African national colours arrives at the stadium
Dance: Many of those inside the stadium were dancing to celebrate the life of the former leader
Tribute: Many of those attending the memorial were decked out in national flags and wearing celebratory clothing
Unity: Mandela is loved by South Africans for his efforts to transform the racially divided country into the 'Rainbow Nation'
Meanwhile, ordinary South Africans today paid tribute to the powerful influence Mr Mandela had on their lives.
Matlhogonolo Mothoagae, a postgraduate marketing student who arrived hours before the stadium gates opened, said: 'I would not have the life I have today if it was not for him. He was jailed so we could have our freedom.'
Rohan Laird, the 54-year-old CEO of a health insurance company, said he grew up during white rule in a 'privileged position' as a white South African and that Mandela helped whites work through a burden of guilt.
'His reconciliation allowed whites to be released themselves,' Lair said. 'I honestly don't think the world will see another leader like Nelson Mandela.'
People blew on vuvuzelas, the plastic horn that was widely used during the World Cup soccer tournament in 2010, and sang songs from the era of the anti-apartheid struggle decades ago.
Matlhogonolo Mothoagae, a postgraduate marketing student who arrived hours before the stadium gates opened, said: 'I would not have the life I have today if it was not for him. He was jailed so we could have our freedom.'
Rohan Laird, the 54-year-old CEO of a health insurance company, said he grew up during white rule in a 'privileged position' as a white South African and that Mandela helped whites work through a burden of guilt.
'His reconciliation allowed whites to be released themselves,' Lair said. 'I honestly don't think the world will see another leader like Nelson Mandela.'
People blew on vuvuzelas, the plastic horn that was widely used during the World Cup soccer tournament in 2010, and sang songs from the era of the anti-apartheid struggle decades ago.
Passion: The huge number of mourners at the ceremony is testimony to the impact Mandela made on his country
Carnival atmosphere: Even before the start of the service thousands had gathered to celebrate the life of the former president
Drizzle: But mourners were not deterred by the rain in Johannesburg as they arrived at the stadium
Hero: Mandela's death has united South Africa in mourning for the past five days
Father of the country: Many, like this little boy, refer to the former president using his tribal name, Madiba
'It
is a moment of sadness celebrated by song and dance, which is what we
South Africans do,' said Xolisa Madywabe, CEO of a South African
investment firm.
The 95,000-capacity soccer venue was
also the spot where Mandela made his last public appearance at the
closing ceremony of the World Cup.
After the memorial, his body will lie
in state for three days at the Union Buildings in Pretoria, once the
seat of white power, before burial on Sunday in his rural childhood
village of Qunu in Eastern Cape Province.
Police
promised tight security, locking down roads for miles around the
stadium. However, the first crowds entered the stadium without being
searched.
John Allen, a
48-year-old pastor from the U.S. state of Arkansas, said he once met
Mandela at a shopping center in South Africa with his sons.
Springboks: South Africa's rugby captain Jean de Villiers and his predecessor Francois Pienaar were among the mourners
United: When Mandela handed the rugby world cup to Pienaar it was considered a landslide moment in the post-apartheid era
Image: Supporters bore newspapers with Mandela on the front page as they filed in to the service
Politics: A supporter waves the flag of the
African National Congress, the liberation movement which became
Mandela's political party
Banner: Supporters carrying a large sign which
paid tribute to Mandela's lasting legacy in South Africa and the rest of
the world
ICONIC STADIUM WHERE MANDELA MADE LANDMARK SPEECH IN 1990
The 95,000-capacity football stadium where the memorial is being held is a fitting location to pay tribute to Nelson Mandela.
The First National Bank Stadium, more commonly known as the FNB Stadium, is based in Soweto, the Johannesburg township that was a stronghold of support for the anti-apartheid struggle that Mandela embodied as a prisoner of white rule for 27 years.
It was the place where the iconic leader chose to make his first speech in Johannesburg after his release from prison in 1990.
And it was also the venue where he made his last public appearance at the closing ceremony of the 2010 World Cup.
The First National Bank Stadium, more commonly known as the FNB Stadium, is based in Soweto, the Johannesburg township that was a stronghold of support for the anti-apartheid struggle that Mandela embodied as a prisoner of white rule for 27 years.
It was the place where the iconic leader chose to make his first speech in Johannesburg after his release from prison in 1990.
And it was also the venue where he made his last public appearance at the closing ceremony of the 2010 World Cup.
'He
joked with my youngest and asked if he had voted for Bill Clinton,'
Allen said. 'He just zeroed in on my eight-year-old for the three to
five minutes we talked.'
Mr Obama's tribute came after numerous comparisons were made between him and Mandela - they were both the first black
presidents of their respective countries and living symbols of
struggles to overcome deep-seated racial tensions.
Adding to that, both were awarded the Nobel Peace Prize.
But
as
Obama prepared to honour Mandela , people close to the U.S. president
say he is wary of drawing close comparisons between his own rapid rise
through America's political ranks and Mandela's 27 years in prison
fighting against a repressive
government.
Former President George H.W. Bush, the
only other living U.S. president, will not attend because the
89-year-old is no longer able to travel long distances, his spokesman
Jim McGrath said.
Also traveling with Obama were national security adviser Susan Rice and Attorney General Eric Holder.
For
Obama, who was too young to be active in the American civil rights
movement, it was Mandela's struggle against apartheid that first drew
him into politics.
He
studied Mandela's speeches and writings while studying at Occidental
College from 1979-81 and became active in campus protests against the
apartheid government.
Queues: Members of the public clutching umbrellas to protect against the rain file in to the stadium in Soweto
Getting ready: Crowds have been piling up around
the First National Bank stadium where Mandela's memorial service will
be held on Tuesday
Filling the seats: The stadium, dubbed 'Soccer City', holds 90,000 but there have been overflow areas planned in advance
Paternal: Mandela was often known at 'Tata', or 'Father', by South Africans grateful for his legacy
Rather than view
himself as a counterpart to Mandela, Obama has said he sees himself as
one of the countless millions who drew inspiration from Mandela's life.
'Like
so many around the globe, I cannot fully imagine my own life without
the example that Nelson Mandela set, and so long as I live, I will do
what I can to learn from him,' Obama said after Mandela died last week
at the age of 95.
In the
days following Mandela's death, Obama began crafting the 20-minute
speech he will deliver during Tuesday's service in Johannesburg, where
tens of thousands of South Africans and dozens of foreign dignitaries
are expected to pack a sports stadium.
Obama
is expected to speak of Mandela's influence on South Africa and on his
own life, while also reflecting on the complexity of Mandela's rise from
anti-apartheid fighter and prisoner to president and global icon.
Air Force One touched down at a military base near Johannesburg on Tuesday morning.
Festive: Men singing in the queue for the ceremony at South Africa's largest football stadium
Prepared: People filled the stadium on Tuesday hours before the dignitaries arrived
Downpout: The rain did not deter the good-natured crowds and provided a business opportunity for entrepreneurial bystanders
'My
very first political action, the first thing I ever did that involved
an issue or a policy or politics, was a protest against apartheid,'
Obama said last week.
'The day that (Mandela) was released
from prison gave me a sense of what human beings can do when they're
guided by their hopes and not by their fears.'
By
the time Obama became president, Mandela had retired from public life.
But they did have one in-person meeting, a hastily arranged 2005
encounter while Mandela was visiting Washington.
The
South African leader had been encouraged to meet a young black U.S.
senator who was a rising star in American politics and invited Obama to
visit him at his hotel.
His final appearance: It was in 'Soccer City' in
2010 where former President Mandela was last seen publicly before he
stopped going to large events due to his ailing health
Inspiration: 14-year-old Thomas looks out across the arena as the crowds start to file in for the memorial service
Programme: The events were scheduled to include talks by world leaders as well as tributes from Mandela's family
Outside: A mourner holding a South African flag on the outskirts of the FNB Stadium this morning
Homestead: A woman in Mandela's village of Qunu stokes a fire as his memorial service plays on TV behind her
A
single photo from the meeting shows the two men smiling and shaking
hands, with Obama standing and Mandela sitting, his legs stretched out
in front of him.
The photo hangs in Obama's personal office at the White House, as well as in Mandela's office in Johannesburg.
Obama and Mandela had sporadic contact
after that meeting, including a congratulatory phone call from Mandela
after Obama's 2008 election and a condolences call from the U.S.
president after the South African's granddaughter was killed in a 2010
car accident.
Touching down: President Obama and First Lady
Michelle looked collected and sombre after coming off the 17-hour flight
on Air Force One
Welcoming committee: President Obama and
Michelle (who is covered by an umbrella) are greeted Tuesday morning on
the tarmac in Johannesburg by International Relations Minister Maite
Nkoane-Mashabane (center)
Former President George W. Bush and his wife
Laura are seen coming off of Air Force One after the Obamas as the two
couples shared the plane with former Secretary of State and first lady
Hillary Clinton
Lines of succession: Obama led the Americans,
followed by Michelle, then former President George Bush, Laura Bush, and
Hillary Clinton seen just slightly at the end
Not attending: Russia's president Vladimir Putin
today signed a book of condolence for Mandela's death at the South
African embassy in Moscow
In 2011,
Mrs Obama and her two daughters held a private meeting with Mandela
during a visit to South Africa but the elderly leader was hospitalized
and too sick to meet with Obama when he traveled there earlier this
year.
Mandela's ailing
health cast a shadow over that trip, heightening the emotion when Obama
and his family visited the Robben Island prison where Mandela spent 18
of his 27 years in prison.
Obama
also met with members of Mandela's family during his July visit and the
White House said he hopes to spend time with them again on Tuesday.
Zimbabwe President Robert Mugabe and his wife Grace Mugabe (centre) arrive in Pretoria ahead of the memorial
Equatorial Guinea's president Teodoro Obiang
Nguema Mbasogo (left) and Kenya's President Uhuru Kenyatta (right) also
arrived in South Africa on Monday night
Pakistani President Mamnoon Hussain (centre) is also on the guestlist for the prestigious memorial
Uganda's President Yoweri Museveni (left) and
Malawi's President Joyce Banda (right) arrive at Waterkloof Air Force
Base in Pretoria
No comments:
Post a Comment